Garment vs. Pigment Dyed T-Shirts
min read

Garment vs. Pigment Dyed T-Shirts

Explore the differences between garment-dyed and pigment-dyed t-shirts.

Regarding t-shirts, one of the most essential items in any wardrobe, not all are created equal. 

The world of t-shirt manufacturing offers a fascinating array of options, and one critical aspect to consider is how the shirt is dyed. Maybe you haven’t considered it, but it is important nonetheless.

We’ve been in the custom apparel business for over a decade, and we have seen an increase in popularity regarding garment and pigment-dyed t-shirts over the years- very  trendy, and we don’t see the hype going away any time soon!

In this article, we'll delve into the differences between garment and pigment-dyed t-shirts, and maybe sharing am option or two for you to check out yourself. *wink*

Garment-Dyed T-Shirts: A Softer Touch

Garment dyeing is a process that takes place after the t-shirt has been cut, sewn, and entirely constructed. It's as if the shirt is "born" in a neutral color, and its final hue is applied. This approach allows the dye to penetrate the entire garment, including the fabric and seams. The result? A t-shirt that feels incredibly soft to the touch.

The benefit of this method is that the dye permeates the fabric fibers thoroughly, resulting in a consistent and even color distribution. When you put on a garment-dyed t-shirt, it feels comfortable and worn in from the very beginning. The softness and suppleness of the fabric make it a favorite among those seeking comfort without sacrificing style.

Additionally, garment-dyed t-shirts maintain their vibrant colors for extended periods compared to their pigment-dyed counterparts. The dye is less likely to fade quickly, even after multiple rounds in the washing machine.

Pigment-Dyed T-Shirts: A Vintage Aesthetic

On the other hand, pigment-dyeing is an entirely different approach to coloring t-shirts. Instead of immersing the entire garment in dye, pigment dyeing involves applying the color directly to the fabric's surface. The dye "sits" on the material, creating a more faded, vintage, or distressed appearance.

One of the defining characteristics of pigment-dyed t-shirts is their texture and rugged look. Because the dye doesn't penetrate as deeply into the fabric, you may notice color variations, especially along seams and edges. This gives the shirt a unique and distinctive character that appeals to those who appreciate the vintage or lived-in aesthetic.

Pigment-dyed t-shirts have a slightly stiffer feel than their garment-dyed counterparts, especially when new. However, wearing and washing often make them softer and more comfortable, developing their charm.

Texture and Feel

The texture and feel of garment-dyed t-shirts are characterized by softness, immediate comfort, and a smooth surface. On the other hand, pigment-dyed t-shirts offer a textured, slightly rougher feel initially, with color variations that give them a vintage charm. 

Your choice between the two depends on whether you prioritize immediate comfort and softness or are drawn to the rugged, textured, and vintage aesthetic of pigment-dyed t-shirts.

Garment-Dyed T-Shirts

These shirts are prized for their softness and smoothness. The thorough dye penetration results in a fabric that feels comfortable and broken in from the moment you put it on. If you value comfort, garment-dyed t-shirts may be your top choice.

Here's why garment-dyed t-shirts feel the way they do:

  1. Softness: Garment-dyed t-shirts have an exceptionally soft and smooth feel. The dye permeates the fabric thoroughly, so no harsh, abrasive textures exist. When you slip into a garment-dyed t-shirt, it's like wrapping yourself in a cloud of comfort.
  1. Comfort from the Start: One of the most significant advantages of garment dyeing is that it eliminates the need for the wearer to break in the shirt. It feels comfortable and worn in from the beginning as if you've owned it for years. This immediate comfort particularly appeals to those who prioritize softness and comfort in their clothing.
  1. Flexible and Supple: The fabric of garment-dyed t-shirts tends to be more flexible and supple. It drapes elegantly on the body, conforming to your movements without feeling restrictive. This flexibility adds to the overall comfort and wearability of these t-shirts.
  1. Smooth Seams: Since the entire t-shirt, including the seams, is dyed as a whole, you won't encounter any rough or uneven textures along the seams. The seams blend seamlessly with the fabric, ensuring a comfortable fit.

Pigment-Dyed T-Shirts

Pigment dyeing imparts a unique texture to the fabric. The dye resting on the surface creates a slightly rougher, more textured feel. While it might feel stiffer initially, many people appreciate the gradual softening with wear, giving the shirt character and making it even more comfortable.

Pigment dyed t-shirts offer a different tactile experience, characterized by a distinct texture and feel:

  1. Textured Surface: Pigment dyeing involves applying the dye directly to the fabric's surface, creating a textured appearance. As a result, pigment-dyed t-shirts often have a slightly rougher texture, especially when they are brand new. This textured surface is what contributes to their unique and rugged look.
  1. Vintage Aesthetic: Many are drawn to pigment-dyed t-shirts precisely because of their textured, vintage appearance. The unevenness in color and texture gives the shirt a charming, weathered look reminiscent of well-worn, beloved clothing.
  1. Initial Stiffness: Pigment-dyed t-shirts can feel stiffer when you first wear them than garment-dyed shirts. However, this stiffness tends to soften and mellow with each wash and wear. Over time, the shirt becomes more comfortable, all while retaining its distinctive texture.
  1. Variations in Color: Because the dye does not penetrate the fabric as deeply as in garment dyeing, you may notice variations in color, especially around seams and edges. These variations contribute to the unique, lived-in appearance of pigment-dyed t-shirts.

Color Variation and Aging

The color variation and how these shirts age over time are also crucial factors.

Garment-Dyed T-Shirts

Due to the thorough dye penetration, these shirts typically have a more consistent and even color throughout the garment. The colors remain vibrant and are less prone to fading, especially with proper care.

Pigment-Dyed T-Shirts

Pigment-dyed shirts are known for their color variations and the vintage, weathered look they develop. With time and repeated washing, you may notice the colors subtly changing and evolving, which adds to their character. Some people seek out pigment-dyed shirts precisely because they give their clothing a unique, lived-in appearance.

Durability and Longevity

Some noteworthy differences regarding longevity and how well these shirts hold up over time exist.

Garment-Dyed T-Shirts

Garment-dyed shirts often excel in terms of color retention. The dye has deeply penetrated the fabric fibers, making it less likely to fade quickly. This makes them a solid choice for those who want their t-shirts to maintain their original colors for an extended period.

Pigment-Dyed T-Shirts

Pigment-dyed shirts may fade more rapidly, especially with repeated washing and prolonged exposure to sunlight. However, the fading is often part of the desired aesthetic for those who love the vintage look.

Some Of Our Garment and Pigment Dyed Picks 

One is a t-shirt, one is a crewneck. What can we say… we wanted to spice things up a bit. Why not, ya know?

Los Angeles Apparel 1801GD

Made of 100% USA cotton, this t-shirt is beefy, durable, absorbent, and is virtually shrink free as a result of garment dyeing. It includes a heavy and sturdy feel, combined with a more generous fit and higher neckline.

Independent Trading Co PRM3500

Independent Trading Co. crewneck sweatshirts are popular choices for customization, such as screen printing or embroidery. Many organizations, schools, and businesses use these sweatshirts as a canvas for branding and personalization.

Wanna See For Yourself?

The choice between garment-dyed and pigment-dyed t-shirts ultimately comes down to your style and preferences. 

Garment-dyed shirts offer a soft, comfortable, and consistently colored option, while pigment-dyed shirts provide a more textured, vintage appearance that evolves. 

Consider how you plan to wear and care for your t-shirts, and let your taste guide your decision. Whether you opt for the soft embrace of garment-dyed or the rugged charm of pigment-dyed, you will find a t-shirt that suits your unique style.

For information on fabric types and how our inks react with them, download our T-Shirt Fabric Guide. 

If you'd like to learn more or talk to one of our printing pros, please reach out!  Our team is here to help guide you through your custom apparel ordering process. We can answer any* questions you may have.

*Except maybe ‘which came first – the chicken or the egg?”

 Sorry to disappoint.

Custom T-Shirt Buyer's Guide Mockup

Get our free Custom T-Shirt Buyer's Guide

A 25+ page how-to guide full of tips, tricks, and money-saving recommendations.
Thank you! Check your email, the guide is headed your way!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.